Netanyahu will be Prime Minister: What now for Israel?

by Edward Crocker on 20th February 2009 at 17:33
Benjamin Netanyahu and Me
Creative Commons License photo credit: ZoomGalaxy

The big news today is that Israel’s President Shimon Peres has selected Binyamin Netanyahu – leader of the right-wing Likud Party – to form the next government. This announcement comes two weeks after the results of the Israel elections, where the moderate Kadima party, headed by Tzipi Livni, beat Likud by one seat. Despite Livni’s victory, however, it was obvious from the start that Netanyahu (pictured, on the left) would likely be the one chosen to form a government, as he is able to scrape together a bigger coalition of right-wing parties than Livni can of left-wing ones. This outcome became near inevitable yesterday when extreme right-wing leader Avigdor Lieberman -whose party “Israel is our home” came a decent third place in the elections – fulfilled his kingmaker role by vowing to support Netanyahu. Following Peres’s decision today, we now know for certain that  Netanyahu will be the next Prime Minister of Israel.  (For more on the election results and  the coalition alternatives, see my post Israel Election Results: Your guess is as good as mine)

The key question now is what the government he chooses to form will look like. Netanyahu has already reached out to  Livni, as well as Ehud Barak of the left wing Labour Party, no doubt realising that a fringe right-wing coaltion government will be unlikely to accomplish much and receive little support from the U.S. – at least not from the new Obama administration. Indeed, he is reportedly ready to offer Livni the job of  foreign minister and deputy prime minister, as well as the role of defense secretary to her deputy Shaul Mofaz. However, both Livni and Ehud Barak have signalled that they would rather stay in opposition than form a government with Netanyahu – Livni unwilling to be a “figleaf” for a right-wing administration- and thus a unity government must be considered the less likely option.

If Netanyahu does end up having to form a right-wing government, then the prospects for the two-state solution – and thus a real peace process – could be disastrous. In my next post I will explore why the two-state solution would be off the table and, more importantly, what happens if it is. (Hint: nothing good)

Israel Election Results: Your guess is as good as mine

by Edward Crocker on 11th February 2009 at 17:43

In what can only be described as an unhelpful result, it looks like Israel’s elections, with 99% of the votes counted, have produced a tiny lead for the moderate Kadima party over the right-wing Likkud. Kadima, led by Tzipi Livni, (pictured) have 28 seats while Binyamin “Bibi” Netanyahu’s Likkud has 27, with seriously right-wing candidate and potential King-maker Avigdor Lieberman at 15 seats and Ehud Barak’s Labour party with a disastrous 13. The rest of the seats in Israel’s parliament – the Knesset – will be divided between a seemingly endless array of left wing and right wing parties, with what looks like a substantial seat advantage for the right-wingers.

The first observation to make is that, even by the standards of most complicated proportional representation systems, Israel would probably have been better off just drawing lots. The second is that you might well expect Livni’s chances of helming any coalition to be very strong, given her victory, however narrow. But you’d be wrong. What happens next is that President  Shimon Peres will meet with all the party heads and choose someone to come up with a coalition – that someone being chosen not for their party’s numerical lead but for the likelihood of them being able to put together a majority alliance. Given the gains for the right-wing parties, that someone could just as easily be Netanyahu as Livni- which as we shall see is not a pleasant thought.

Read more…